1.who are you talking with on the phone?2.who are talking with you on the phone

题目

1.who are you talking with on the phone?2.who are talking with you on the phone
which one is right ,why?

答案

第一句.
您可先将第一句转换成陈述句应为：you are talking with somebody on the phone.然后对人提问,疑问代词who放在句首,紧跟be动词,再加陈述句语序,最后加问号.
第二句转换成陈述句为某人现在正跟你讲话,好像不符合现在进行时态的逻辑,如果是第三者描述这件事的情景,句中的第三人sonebody作主语应该用过去进行时,如用现在进行时,语序应像第一句用you做主语.
我觉得第二句主要有人称和时态逻辑对应问题.
By the way,I'm not professional.